stafacon.de

From the community · not an official site

Critical
Voices.

Here, people who have something to add to the debate get to speak. One person, one photo, one statement in their own words, and below it the links they choose to give. No editor in between, no trimming, no rewriting.

01

The entries

Red panda fursuit head with the tongue sticking out, holding a blue plush toy. The background is blurred: a tree trunk and green leaves.
AI is not art. AI is a waste of resources and a contempt for art. Generative AI systems are not artists — they are and remain machines. They understand nothing of what makes art. As a furry and a photographer, I speak out decisively against AI.

Akira Haru (@kattbjoernar)
Photographer and member of the furry community in Rhineland-Palatinate, Germany

As a furry (fursuit maker), cosplayer, artist and media technologist in digital printing xD, I deal with prints, advertising and media every single day! And the amount of AI slop I hold in my hands every day is INSANE! Everything looks equally awful. AI hates empty spaces and plasters them with all sorts of things, an absolute overload of stimuli. I also don’t understand why it has become so hard for people to simply take a PHOTO when, for example, they want to present products. No, they’d rather type in a prompt, because they’re too lazy to pull out their phone, point the camera and press the shutter.

It simply hurts to see how pleased people who generate such images are to now have a “great” poster at hand out of nowhere, one that would not have been possible at all without the artists whose work was fed to the AI – without even briefly considering that very many people who like drawing, designing, creating, and who have practised and learned for years, would be happy if someone asked them to design that poster.

And the reason “but I can’t draw” is not a valid reason. Nobody is perfect from the start; behind this supposed “talent” there are years of practising, getting better, learning, understanding, falling down again and again and getting back up to keep practising and getting better.

Generating an AI image or something similar and putting yourself on the same level as an artist who works on art for half their life, and comparing yourself to them, tramples on us.

And finally: every drawn poster, every even so “unprofessional” photo, every handmade piece is by far more beautiful and more pleasant than seeing the same AI crap over and over again. Menus all look equally unappetising, posters all equally soulless.

That is why it is all the worse to see something like this at an event where creative people of all kinds come together to talk about their hobbies and what they enjoy, and to have a good time.

Tatsu
Furry (fursuit maker), cosplayer, artist and media technologist in digital printing

About the wording: translated from German. The statement is the author's, not mine. The spelling and punctuation mistakes in the German original were corrected lightly, nothing else was changed.

02

Take part

This page is open. Anyone with something to say about the matter can be on it — with a photo, a name and the links they want listed. I take contributions that deal with the question of whether a convention should let an AI draw its flagship artwork. No attacks on people, no advertising.

If you want to contribute: a few sentences that should stand as written, and a photo if you like. The submission bot takes both, asks before sending whether the contribution may be published, and gives you a reference number.

03

The artwork behind this site

The same image as on the front page: “Cliff at dusk”, painted by Wren, who takes commissions. No generator, no prompts — a person who decided what is in the picture, and who should be paid for it.

A red panda wrapped in a blanket sits on a cliff, looking out over the sea at dusk; a constellation stands above in the sky. Digital painting by Wren.
“Cliff at dusk” — painted by Wren · VGen · Instagram
Community Voices